1.
How are the system
drawdowns caused?
2. I
have noticed that
the medium term systems
sometimes only trade
once or twice a week
and then they will
trade 2 - 3 times
in one day? Why is
this happening?
3. Do
you expect the current
performance to continue?
4.
How can one system
sell and at the same
time be buying same
currency pair?
5.
Why do you trade so
many different systems?
6. What
account size is recommended
to trade your systems?
7. What
is the maximum drawdown
that I would need
to plan for either
Multiphase or Cyclone?
8. Do
you keep many open
trades?
9. Do
you offer a free trial
period for your systems?
10.
Do you have more trading
history performance
dating earlier than
Nov 2005? If so, what
are the results?
11.
Is your system purely
mechanical?
12.
How long have these
systems traded in
a live account?
1.
How are the system
drawdowns caused?
System drawdown as
it is used here is
defined as the largest
drop in system equity
across the entire
testing period.
The spot forex
markets are quite
volatile - which
opens the possibilities
of significantly
profitable moves.
However, the downside
to all this is
the possibility
- or rather the
certainty - of
occasional drawdowns.
Check the charts
below of the GBPUSD
Long Term trades
that occurred
between 6-7-06
and 7-3-06. These
two back-to-back
trades were the
ones that created
the published
drawdown for this
system - over
$12,000.

Although the losses
on these trades
were more than recovered
over the next two
weeks, the fact
remains that these
types of drawdowns
WILL OCCUR
with this system.
To be a successful
system trader you
must first realize
that these drawdown
events will occur
and are a part of
system trading and
second, you must
have the mind set
to stay with the
system through these
difficult periods.
Many traders think
that they can
stand these drawdowns
/ losses, but
when real money
is at stake they
often panic and
withdraw from
system trading
just before the
big profitable
trades occur.
First of all, be
sure that your account
is properly capitalized
for the system you
are trading by starting
with an account
balance that is
at least 50% greater
than the maximum
drawdown historically
experienced by the
system.
Second, discipline
yourself to stay
with the system.
Although these points
do not automatically
guarantee profitable
system trading,
they will take you
a long way toward
that goal.
2.
I have noticed
that the medium
term systems sometimes
only trade once
or twice a week
and then they will
trade 2 - 3 times
in one day? Why
is this happening?
The chart below
from July 28, 2006
illustrates this
trading pattern.
Note that the system
changed positions
5 times during the
day, 4 on consecutive
bars.
This can occur when
the market has been
sideways, or trendless,
for a considerable
period of time.
The parallel functions
that define the
market trend can
be flipped from
long to short quite
frequently during
congestion phases
such as these and,
therefore, re-define
the trend much more
frequently than
during the more
common trending
periods.
While seen infrequently,
these patterns are
part of the normal
behavior of the
system. When the
market re-enters
a trending mode
the system will
once again display
the usual trading
patterns.
3.
I have to say that
your Multiphase
System has made
quite a start on
FX-AUTO during the
month of July 2006..
Do you expect it
to continue as successfully
in the future, for
example under different
trading conditions?
Although self-correcting,
would you expect
some negative weeks
/ months until correction,
or will it churn
out good positive
pips every month?
First of all, there
are no guarantees
in trading and it
is entirely possible
that successive
months will not
be as profitable
or, for that matter,
profitable at all.
These systems are
designed to be self-adaptive
in that they are
constantly adjusting
their parameters
for changing market
conditions, but
this is not a guarantee
that they will always
be profitable. If
market conditions
change too frequently
there may not be
sufficient time
for these adjustments
to be made.
To better answer
your specific question,
let's examine the
actual real time
performance of the
systems in July
2006 to the projections
created by developmental
system testing over
historical data.
Please review this
disclaimer
prior to continuing
as the following
illustrations take
into consideration
hypothetical testing
data.
During the month
of July, real time
trading of the Multphase
Systems has resulted
in a net profit
of $32,897.91 and
the Cyclone Forex
System had generated
$7,039.43.
Testing projections
predict that Multiphase
should generate
$46,388.63 and Cyclone
should produce $11220.63
on an AVERAGE monthly
basis.
So while the real
time profits achieved
seem impressive,
they are less than
system testing had
projected for the
average month.
What does this then
tell us? Hypothetical
backtesting represents
the optimum performance
for the designated
system over back
data - to achieve
these results in
real time trading
would require that
identical market
conditions repeat
themselves, which
is not likely. Obviously
and logically then
we should expect
somewhat lower performance
in real time trading,
which we have observed
during the month
of July, 2006.
4.
How can one system
sell and at the
same time be buying
same currency pair?
We are actually
trading 3 separate
systems within the
Multiphase system
for
GBPUSD - a short
term, medium term
and long term strategy.
These systems
are designed to
define and trade
with the trend
on different
( short, medium
and long ) time
frames, and thus
can occasionally
take
positions in opposite
directions. This
happens when the
market is in a
sideways, or consolidation
phase during which
trend definition
is not as
clear as when
the market is
trending in one
direction or another.
When the market
breaks out of trendless
mode the positions
in the direction
of the trend are
maintained and will
remain with the
new trend until
reversed or until
they reach their
various self-adaptive
target points. The
positions that are
against the new
trend will either
be stopped out or
more
likely, reversed
in the direction
of the new trend.
Frequently these
positions against
the new trade are
stopped out for
small losses that
are
significantly less
than the profits
being achieved by
the positions in
the
direction of the
new major trend.
5.
Why do you trade
so many different
systems?
This use of several
systems on multiple
time frames in effect
acts as a
hedge when the market
is in a sideways
mode. We will usually
have a position
in the right direction
when the breakout
occurs.
This is actually
a form of diversification.
Most traders are
familiar with
the concept of diversifying
a stock portfolio
by owning many stocks
of
different characteristics,
volatility, or industry
groups in an attempt
to "
smooth out "
the gyrations of
the market.
You can also achieve
diversification
on a single item,
in this case GBPUSD,
by trading several
systems with separate
approaches across
separate time
frames. Over time
this strategy has
proven to significantly
improve the
profit picture of
our test accounts.
6.
What account size
is recommended to
trade your systems?
Account
size recommendations
are detailed here.
7.
What is the maximum
drawdown that I
would need to plan
for either Multiphase
or Cyclone?
Drawdowns
for all the systems
can be found on
the testing
pages.
8.
Do you keep many
open trades? I have
been monitoring
trade systems on
FX-Auto for about
6 months, and I
have seen many systems
start out
profitable. However
most of these systems
had several negative
trades open.
So when they closed,
all pips were lost.
No, we
do not maintain
multiple open trades
in the anticipation
that they may eventually
turn profitable
and then help the
track record. All
trades recorded
are actual system
trades only.
However, with the
potential of 12
systems trading
simultaneously we
can have greater
than 10 - 12 positions
actively open an
any given time.
9.
Do you offer a free
trial period for
your systems?
No.
10. Do you have
more trading history
performance dating
earlier than
Nov 2005? If so,
what are the results?
No. The
systems are developed
on tick based charts.
The amount of data
available on the
TradeStation Data
Network is limited,
thus limiting the
back testing capability
of the systems.
11. Is your
system purely mechanical?
Yes. The system
is entirely technically
based, with now
allowances for holiday
periods, news events,
economic reports,
etc. For a detailed
discussion on the
use of the parallel
function programming
that drives these
systems please click
here.
12. How
long have these
systems traded in
a live account?
All systems have
been trading in
a live account beginning
June 30, 2006.
|